Unlocking the Heart Sink Puzzle: Navigating the Complex Relationship Between Physiotherapists and Challenging Patients

11 Unlocking the Heart Sink Puzzle Navigating the Complex Relationship Between Physiotherapists and Challenging Patients


The concept of a ‘heart sink’ patient and a ‘heart sink’ physiotherapist, as described in Alastair Santhouse’s book “Head First,” sheds light on the challenging dynamics that can occur between healthcare providers and patients. 

This term captures the emotional and psychological burden experienced by both parties when they feel frustrated, helpless, or overwhelmed during their interactions.

When I read this book, it made me reflect on the times when I would come out to meet a patient whom I considered had given up on treatment or had ulterior motives for seeing me. Both scenarios didn’t put me in the best frame of mind. As I reflect now, I can see how this was a lose-lose situation for both parties.

I wanted to write this article to help others understand how a negative mindset can influence the therapeutic relationship and hopefully provide some ideas on managing the situation.

The ‘Heart Sink’ Patient

A ‘heart sink’ patient refers to an individual whose complex medical condition or difficult personality traits contribute to a sense of despair or hopelessness among healthcare professionals. 

These patients often present with chronic pain, multiple health issues, or mental health challenges that require long-term care and attention. They may also exhibit non-compliance with treatment plans, have unrealistic expectations, or demonstrate frequent attendance at medical appointments without significant improvement in their condition. Dealing with such patients can be emotionally draining for healthcare providers, leading to a sense of helplessness and frustration.

The ‘Heart Sink’ Physiotherapist

On the other hand, a ‘heart sink’ physiotherapist describes a healthcare professional who experiences a profound sense of demoralisation and inadequacy when facing the complexities of some patient care. 

Physiotherapists, like any other healthcare provider, invest immense effort in delivering quality care, compassion, and expertise. However, when faced with patients who present significant challenges, such as poor prognosis, limited treatment options, or lack of motivation to participate actively in rehabilitation, physiotherapists may feel that their efforts are futile. 

This leads to a depletion of emotional resilience, negatively impacting their overall job satisfaction and well-being. It also influences how they communicate with the patient.

Implications for Patient Care:

The ‘heart sink’ phenomenon has important implications for patient care and healthcare systems as a whole.

When healthcare providers experience these feelings, it can potentially affect their ability to provide optimal care, leading to a cycle of dissatisfaction and burnout. Recognising and addressing this issue is crucial for maintaining the overall well-being of both patients and healthcare professionals.

Challenges Faced by ‘Heart Sink’ Physiotherapists

When a ‘heart sink’ physiotherapist meets a ‘heart sink’ patient, the encounter can be particularly challenging and emotionally draining for both parties involved. The physiotherapist, already feeling demoralised and inadequate, may find themselves overwhelmed by the complex needs and difficult personality traits of the patient. 

The patient’s chronic pain, multiple health issues, or mental health challenges may exacerbate the physiotherapist’s feelings of helplessness and frustration. This combination can create a toxic cycle where the physiotherapist’s diminishing motivation and confidence further contribute to the patient’s non-compliance or lack of progress. 

It becomes crucial for both the physiotherapist and patient to receive support and intervention to break this cycle and foster a more positive therapeutic relationship.

10 tips on addressing the ‘heart sink’ phenomenon before going into see a patient

  1.  Reflect on your own mindset: Before going into see a patient, take a moment to reflect on your own mindset and emotions. Recognise any negative biases or preconceived notions you may have about the patient and consciously work towards approaching the interaction with an open mind.
  2.  Practice empathy: Put yourself in the patient’s shoes and try to understand their perspective. Empathy can help you build a connection with the patient and create a more positive therapeutic relationship.
  3.  Active listening: Actively listen to the patient’s concerns and validate their feelings. Show genuine interest in what they have to say and make them feel heard and understood.
  4.  Set realistic expectations: Be transparent with the patient about their condition and treatment options. Set realistic expectations regarding outcomes and progress. This can help manage both the patient’s and your own frustrations.
  5.  Collaborate with the patient: Involve the patient in shared decision-making and treatment planning. By giving them a sense of control and ownership over their healthcare journey, you can foster a more positive and collaborative relationship.
  6.  Educate and empower: Provide the patient with information about their condition, treatment options, and self-management strategies. Empower them to take an active role in their own care, which can increase their motivation and engagement.
  7.  Seek support from colleagues: If you find yourself struggling with a ‘heart sink’ patient, don’t hesitate to seek support from your colleagues. Discussing challenging cases with others can provide fresh perspectives and insights that may help you navigate the situation more effectively.
  8.  Practice self-care: Prioritise your own well-being by practicing self-care. Engage in activities that help you relax and recharge outside of work. This can help prevent burnout and improve your overall resilience when dealing with difficult patients.
  9.  Seek professional development opportunities: Continuously enhance your knowledge and skills through professional development opportunities. This can boost your confidence and competence in managing complex cases, reducing feelings of inadequacy.
  10.  Reflect and debrief: Take time to reflect on challenging patient encounters and debrief with a trusted colleague or supervisor. Discussing your experiences and emotions can help you process them and identify strategies for improvement in future interactions.

Remember, addressing the ‘heart sink’ phenomenon requires ongoing effort and self-awareness. By implementing these tips, you can work towards fostering more positive therapeutic relationships and improving patient care outcomes.


In summary, the concept of a ‘heart sink’ patient and a ‘heart sink’ physiotherapist highlights the emotional toll that challenging healthcare dynamics can have on both parties involved. 

Recognising and addressing these feelings is essential for fostering positive therapeutic relationships and maintaining the overall well-being of patients and healthcare professionals. By implementing effective communication strategies and prioritising self-care measures, healthcare systems can strive to mitigate the negative impacts of this phenomenon.

What I offer you and your staff?

Skills practice and reflection will be the cornerstone of my training. I am available for both in person and limited Zoom PD for your group.

If you have a staff member who is struggles keeping new patients or confidently presenting treatment plans, you might be interested in one-on-one coaching for him/her. I take on a limited number of clients each year.

If you would like to engage me to work with your staff or coach a member of your team, click here so that you can schedule a time to discuss your specific training needs.

Contact me to find out when I will be in your city and available for LIVE professional development.

Grab a copy of How to Help Patients
Find Their Own Motivation

Please input your name & email to get access to the download button!

Call +61 417 817 388